You are here
Selecting Scientifically and Evidence-Based Instructional Programs
This brief training covers the differences between core programming, supplemental programming, and intervention. This, in combination with the Selecting an Instructional Program Video found below, can be used as a resource to help guide schools and districts in selecting appropriate curricula and tools.
This short training walks through the use of two tools, The Reading League’s Curriculum Evaluation Tool and CDE’s Core Instructional Programming Rubric, to help guide schools and districts in selecting scientifically and evidence-based instructional programs.
The Reading League’s Curriculum Evaluation Tool identifies green flags for instructional practices that align with the science of reading and red flags for practices that do not. This curriculum evaluation tool features components that align with the Simple View of Reading and Scarborough’s Rope. Word Recognition and Language Comprehension are broken down into subcomponents. Writing, assessment, and overall design are also evaluated.
The Core Instructional Programming Rubric is used as part of the review process for programs to be placed on the Colorado Department of Education’s READ Act Advisory List. The rubric has two phases. In phase one, reviewers are looking for evidence of research alignment, explicit instruction, sequential instruction, systematic and cumulative instruction, coordinated components and related elements that are optimal for delivering effective instruction. If the program meets the minimum threshold of points, it will move onto phase two where it will be reviewed by reading component for each grade level kindergarten through third grade. A program may appear to meet these phase one requirements but on further more detailed review in phase two, reviewers may find evidence might be contrary to the initial, cursory review.
The READ Act requires the department to identify evidence-based instructional programs and professional development programs for use by local education agencies. The CDE Advisory List of Instructional Programming includes links to providers and programs that have been approved through the most recent instructional programming review process completed in 2020. As of March 2021, this list has been updated and is now considered complete.